The Montezuma County commissioners found themselves walking a fine line Tuesday as they struggled to decide what people could say during public comment.
Many people are eager to comment on the proposed Valley Range Energy Park, a 125-megawatt solar energy project southeast of Cortez.
The application is not complete, so the controversial project has not yet been scheduled for a public hearing. https://www.ksjd.org/podcast/ksjd-local-newscasts/2026-11-16/valley-range-application-mancos-flood-recovery
Mary Dodd of Cortez, the second person to speak during the public-comment period, said the benefits of the project are real.
“Empire Electric is one of four rural co-ops that support this project and will benefit from it,” she said.
She asked, “Will we decide our energy future based on facts or based on fear?”
Dodd said the developer, Accelergen Energy, “has willingly and respectfully addressed the publics concerns and questions and will continue to do so.”
County attorney Stephen Tarnowski interrupted her to say the commissioners can take comments on that specific project only during the board’s hearings about it, which are quasi-judicial.
He said people can make comments about solar farms or land use in general.
“If you want to comment broadly on the county’s approach to solar or batteries, I think that is allowed,” Tarnowski said, “but if members of the public do have comments specific to the proposal we’d ask you to please save that.”
Dodd was one of seven people who spoke. Five voiced concerns about solar projects and lithium-ion battery energy storage systems, one of which is proposed for the park.
Lauren Ragland of Dolores said lithium-ion batteries can explode and release toxic fumes in a process called thermal runaway.
“It is an uncontrollable, self-reinforcing, out-of-control process that causes cascading failure,” she said.
She added that Highway 160 is nearby. “In my mind it seems possible we could have a very, very bad situation with the highway if there’s fumes and smoke,” she said.
That led Tarnowski to reiterate that the commissioners can’t consider comments about the project that are made outside of the actual public hearings.
Several citizens suggested the commissioners reinstate a moratorium on solar farms.
“I believe it’s time to reinstate a solar moratorium and re-examine Chapter 10 of the land-use code and reapply it to all present and future renewable-energy applications,” said Eleanor Macfarlane of Montezuma County.
But Nanette Ward of Cortez said using renewable energy makes sense. “Gas and oil exploration, in my mind, as much as I can comprehend, is not exactly clean energy,” she said.
“I would rather live next door to an array of solar panels than to many of the neighboring areas that have yards full of old trucks and trailers and junk and building material.”